how to do up the red dress

i think the best way to start of an outfit is by taking a plain basic and to work off of that. down below we have a pretty plain red sleeveless dress, that i am going to do a few different looks with:

down below:

the first look has been fixed using a large, poncho style tartan jacket, red tights, black shoes and a black hijab.

second in line: a cute black gypsy top - emroidered with tiny flowers, black hijab and flowery square scarf that has been folded into a triangle and wrapped around the neck and across the chest. its matched with red shoes and a deeper red bag.

third look: reverse look with the shoes and tights, a big square bag, black hijab - large loose jacket and to really add distraction a long monochromatic tie-dyed scarf has been hung around the neck.

but my favourite alternative look is this one below done up with a heavily striped shawl, two belts across the mid-section (done up loose and with the help of the shawl the belts wont add obvious curves to your appearance), a red beret and a few brooches here and there to complete the look.

which one would you be tempted to wear?